If two witnesses provide conflicting alibis, which step should an officer take first?

• A. Document statements, seek corroboration, and avoid premature conclusions.
• B. Immediately arrest both suspects.
• C. Conclude that one alibi is false and file a report.
• D. Ignore the alibis and rely on personal impressions.

Answer: (A)

When witnesses present conflicting alibis, start with an evidence-based approach: document each statement carefully and in detail, noting times, places, and any inconsistencies. Then seek corroboration by pursuing additional sources — other witnesses, surveillance footage, records, or any physical evidence that can confirm or challenge the alibis. This combination helps you form an accurate, fair picture before drawing conclusions. Rushing to arrest, declaring one alibi false without solid evidence, or ignoring the alibis would risk bias and mistakes and undermine the investigation.